Wednesday, April 05, 2006

Colour TV? Let me have a blue one please!

This Indian Voter is not sure how many people in India take the election manifestos of the political parties seriously. To the best of this writer's knowledge, election manifestos that are released at the respective party headquarters in the full glare of media seldom reach the common people these parties promise to 'serve'. Very often these parties promise much beyond the sun & the moon and that precisely makes the entire exercise a big mockery.

Doling out or rather promising freebies to public is nothing new for the general practitioners of Indian democracy. Only that the form & volume differs.

Way back in 1967, C.N.Annadurai led DMK upset the Congress applecart and stormed to power on the promise of providing 3 quintals of rice for a rupee (ரூபாய்க்கு மூன்று படி அரிசி). M.G.Ramachandran, was in DMK then and he was the star campaigner for the party. It was MGR who championed the "padi arisi thittam" during the election campaign. In the same election, M.G.Ramachandran also got elected to represent the St. Thomas Mount constituency in the TN Assembly (St. Thomas Mount constituency doesn't exist anymore. It is now being called Alandur). DMK couldn't live up to its poll promise and in the next election, Congress coined a slogan "பரங்கிமலை தாத்தா! படி அரிசி தா தா!!" (parangimalai thaathaa, padi arisi thaa thaa) in apparent reference to M.G.Ramachandran.

Not long ago in 1994, another matinee idol - N.T.Rama Rao in Andhra Pradesh captured power on the promise that rice would be made available for Rs 2 a kg. Even about twelve years back, that was considered to be an impractical promise and NTR came in for heavy criticism from those who cared a thing or two about economy.

Another interesting promise, though it didn't find place in the party manifesto was made in 1998 by AIADMK candidate for Tiruchendur parliamentary constituency. If elected, he promised that, he would have his movies filmed within that constituency. Sounds funny or otherwise, he got elected to the parliament in that election. To those of you who are very curious, the candidate is Ramarajan - film star of early 1990s.

Currently, the manifesto brought out by Karunanidhi led DMK has taken the freebies culture to a new level. Apart from promising 'quality rice' at Rs 2 per kilogram, DMK led government, if voted to power would provide every family in Tamilnadu with a new colour television. Population of TN, according to 2001 census is around 60 million (6 crores). For the sake of convenience, assuming that each family comprises of 6 persons, there would be 10 million (1 crore) familes in the state. Again, assuming that the lowest priced colour TV would cost Rs 7000, if DMK is serious about its manifesto, it would cost the exchequer a whopping Rs 7,000 crore. This writer reckons that Palaniappan Chidambaram - the Union Finance Minister and the one who happens to be an important leader of a party in the DMK led alliance would have squirmed in his seats when he learnt of the above. In the past, Chidambaram has rightly discouraged such freebies and when Jayalalithaa government recently doled out cash relief of Rs. 2000 to the flood victims, he so thoughtfully reasoned out the economic mismanagement of such a measure.

For the general public though, this might - alas, sound very interesting. If one party manages to win the election by giving them free colour TVs, wouldn't the next party get them all free Home Cinema sets? Economy? Come on.. Is that very important than 'Selvi' or 'Kolangal'?

P.S: For the uninitiated, 'Selvi', 'Kolangal' are popular mega serials telecast in Sun TV.

11 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

well said

Have linked this post in Desipundit

http://www.desipundit.com/2006/04/05/colortv/

April 06, 2006 3:01 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sun TV is coming out with an IPO exactly for this purpose so that they can buy out some TV companies..

April 06, 2006 9:45 PM  
Blogger Ravi said...

Very well said! For long, I have been wondering if these freebies really make sense because anything given free loses its value. MGR ensured his position firm and strong by his freebies stance and during his period the economy and industrial development was pathetic and are these people shelling these out from their pockets (in crude words "yaaru appan veettu soththu??") Keep posting voter...

April 07, 2006 12:42 PM  
Blogger Ravi said...

First time here and I went thru' all your posts (just after posting my prev comment). You writing style is great and informative and importantly neutral. Please keep more coming.

I would like to know how did the kazhagams manage to get a foot hold in TN and that too when Kamaraj was giving good governance. Weren't the Kazhagams heights of hypocrisy? I read an interesting article here :
http://www.tfmpage.com/my/mani/dravida.html. Maybe you could give your view point(s) too. Thanks!

April 07, 2006 1:25 PM  
Blogger expertdabbler said...

make no mistake,nobody takes an election manifesto seriously:)

>>i cud not conceal my laughter on ramarajan's promise:)

April 07, 2006 10:43 PM  
Blogger Indian Voter said...

Dubukku: Thanks very much for throwing more light on these pages.

Anonymous: MK has said that the cost per TV would be 2000 bucks.. hmmm... they are making doubly sure about the entertainment aspect.

Ravi: Very true.. whose money is it? Poor tax payers.

Thanks again for your encouragement. I will try to give my views on whatever little I know of that. That link was indeed interesting.

Prabu Karthik: To consider that Ramarajan was an MP.. :) thank goodness Jayalalithaa pulled the rug and the parliament got dissolved in 13 months that time.

April 11, 2006 9:42 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

well analysed...

April 12, 2006 8:17 PM  
Blogger hari said...

Hi IV,

Coming to your blog after a very long time. You too were in hibernation for quite long.

Anyway it is sad that the Tamilnadu politicians still consider the public immatured and childish enough to try and lure their votes by Colour TVs.

It is even more sad that the public of Tamilnadu, not reacting strongly to such thoughts, are only proving the politicians right.

April 17, 2006 3:41 PM  
Blogger Kaps said...

You have become famous :-)
http://www.dnaindia.com/report.asp?NewsID=1024900

April 19, 2006 9:09 AM  
Blogger Indian Voter said...

Ashok:: Thanks very much.

Hari:: Indeed, I took a long break and back now in full flow. More than the muted reaction, I am shocked to note that ppl welcome these freebies without realising that it is their money which is being spent.

Eshwar:: Thanks for your comments. Yah.. I did make note of the manifestos. This election seems to be contested over rice.

Kaps:: Thanks very much for letting me know.

April 19, 2006 8:12 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Karunanidhi is announced the free color let him announce plasma darly

April 25, 2006 3:01 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home